Water Engine Fallacy



 

Some Historical Claims 

Multiple "inventors" worldwide have claimed the invenction of engines which run on water alone.

1970 patent

Even nowadays some companys claim they can do it.


These are some of the claims:

  • With the water engine you don't need batteries.
  • You don't need to carry hydrogen cells.
  • All you need is water.
  • Vested interests of large fosil fuel multinationals are making sure water engine doesn't succeed.

An engine that runs just on water





Obtain Hydrogen from Water



Using electrolysis you can break the water molecule H₂O into hydrogen and oxygen. 
Obviously, apart from water you also need an electrical current which has to be supplied by a batttery. 

Electrolysis Energy Requirements

To obtain 1 kilogram of hydrogen from water through electrolysis, it typically requires around 50 to 55 kilowatt-hours (kWh) of electric energy.

Here's a breakdown of the calculation:

Energy Required for Electrolysis: The electrolysis of water to produce hydrogen involves splitting water (H₂O) into hydrogen (H₂) and oxygen (O₂). The theoretical minimum energy required is about 39.4 kWh per kilogram of hydrogen under ideal conditions.

Efficiency of the Electrolyzer: In practice, electrolyzers are not 100% efficient. Modern electrolyzers usually have efficiencies between 65% and 80%. So, to account for inefficiencies, you multiply the theoretical energy requirement by the inverse of the efficiency.


Practical energy requirement: 49.25 to 60.6 kWh

This range accounts for different types of electrolyzers and their varying efficiencies.


Run an Internal Combustion Engine with Hydrogen


The amount of energy an internal combustion engine (ICE) can deliver from 1 kilogram of hydrogen depends on several factors, including the efficiency of the engine and the energy content of hydrogen.

Key Points:

  1. Energy Content of Hydrogen:
    • Hydrogen has a high energy content by weight, with a lower heating value (LHV) of approximately 33.33 kWh per kilogram.
  2. Efficiency of an Internal Combustion Engine (ICE):
    • Internal combustion engines are typically less efficient than fuel cells. The efficiency of a hydrogen-powered ICE can vary, but it is usually between 20% and 30%.

Calculation:

To find out how many kilowatt-hours an ICE can deliver from 1 kg of hydrogen:

  • Energy delivered by the engine = Energy content of hydrogen × Efficiency of the ICE
  • Using a typical efficiency range:

Energy delivered = 33.33 kWh/kg×(0.20 to 0.30) = 6.67 to 10kWh

 

Efficiency of the Water Engine


We can obtain 1 Kg of hydrogen from water by means of electrolysis consuming 50 kWh of electricity.
By burning this hydrogen in an internal combustion engine we obtain 10 kWh of actual mechanical energy in the car. 
Therefore with 50 kWh of electrical energy we have obtained 10 kWh of actual mechanical energy: this gives us an efficiency of 20%

Current Efficiency of an Electric Car


An electric car has an efficiency above 85%. This means four times as much as the "Water engine".

Fuel Cell Alternative

An alternative for the water engine is to use a fuel cell that converts hydrogen to electricity to power an electric car:


This solution would provide a small improvement. 
Now the efficiency would be 34%. 
Still much lower than just an electric car (85%)

Car Power Alternatives



Conclusions:

  1. The so called "Water Engine" doesn't run on water but on electricity.
  2. The "Water Engine" is, therefore, a very poor performance electric engine.
  3. The efficiency of this "Water Engine" is 25% of normal electric engines.
  4. Therefore this "Water Engine" requires to carry batteries 4 times larger than an electric car.
  5. The folly of water-fuelled vehicles

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Design of Experiments (DOE) with Excel

Image
Design of Experiments (DOE) is a very useful process improvement methodology.  Microsoft Excel has some powerful data analysis tools, which I have, successfully, used for DOE. When it comes to analyzing cause and effect, we want to know what process factors affect our outputs.   Correlation and Regression could give us an indication of the main factors, and the extent they affect the outputs. In some cases, there may be interactions among the different factors, or the mathematical relation between factors and outputs may not be linear. In these cases, it is useful to run a systematic set of experiments, to test all possible combinations of factors, to relate them to the outputs. Factorial Experiment Example We want to minimize process loss, and after some brainstorming among the process specialists, we concluded that 5 factors may affect loss. Based on current factor levels, we have selected the following levels to experiment with:    Download this Excel file DOE_w...
Read more

Response Surface Design Of Experiments with Excel

Image
Design of Experiments is a useful methodology for process improvement. The purpose is to find a relationship between process variables we can control and key process outputs in order to increase process capability . You can use Excel statistical analysis tools, Solver, Pivot charts, etc. to plan and analyse the results of these experiments. The first approach is to look for a linear relationship as shown in:   Excel DOE But in some cases this relationship may not be linear, in which case we will try a quadratic model with Response Surface DOE . We will use an example in this Excel file you can download: Download file   ExcelResponseSurface.xlsm   from OneDrive to your PC. In this example we are trying to maximize process yield acting on the critical factors pH , Temperature and Time . We will run the experiments in the Experiments simulation sheet using coded values.   Code pH Temperature Time -1 2 120 7 1 12 150 15 Factorial Experiments We start by ru...
Read more

Virtual Obeya Room

Image
The Obeya room is a "war room" used by process improvement teams to meet and solve critical multi functional problems.  The room walls are lined up with boards, highly visual charts and graphs showing program timing, milestones and progress to date and countermeasures to existing timing or technical problems.  The team meets in this room regularly but team members can also visit the room, which is fully dedicated to the project, throughout the day. What is an Obeya? Obeya Room Benefits Remove organizational barriers Visual management by displaying all relevant data required in the improvement project Encourage a collaborative environment through regular meetings Implement quicker, more effective solutions The whole team knows what is going on in real time Some Practical Constraints in the Implementation Some companies can't afford the luxury of a fully dedicated room Some of the team members may be located far away so they will only attend the meetings The data displayed ...
Read more